A 99, an 84, and a Console That Finally Has a Job
GTA VI landed overnight with the joint-highest Metacritic score ever recorded. Modern Warfare 4 arrived in October as the best-reviewed Call of Duty in years. Between them, the PS5 Pro has at last been handed the workload it was built for — though not quite in the way anyone expected.

GTA VI: a 99, and not one mixed review
Grand Theft Auto VI unlocked at local midnight on Thursday 19 November, rolling west across time zones from New Zealand. The review embargo had lifted the day before, and the numbers are historic.
Metacritic: 99 from 153 critic reviews — tied with Ocarina of Time at the top of the site’s all-time list. Not a single mixed or negative review. OpenCritic: 98, with 100% of critics recommending it. Standard edition $79.99, Ultimate $99.99, PS5 and Xbox Series X|S only. No PC version has been announced.
The praise is remarkably consistent. The open world draws universal admiration for density, reactive NPCs and incidental events. Jason and Lucia’s story lands. The soundtrack — licensed radio plus an original score by Justice — is singled out repeatedly. Combat has more weight, helped by a new Focus slow-motion mechanic, and the reworked Heat and police systems are thrilling once learned.
The criticisms are minor by comparison. Roughly half of reviewers flagged pacing — slow openings, downtime between jobs, a sagging middle. A similar share reported performance dips. Several found the new realism layer — fragile cars, repair costs, daily chores — an acquired taste.
Modern Warfare 4: the series remembers what it is
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 arrived on 23 October across PS5, Xbox Series X|S, PC and Switch 2, at $69.99 standard. Metacritic sits at 84 on PC; OpenCritic has it at 77 with 100% of critics recommending.
The consensus is a return to form. Destructoid and DayOne both scored it 90; GamingTrend called it the series’ most well-rounded entry at 87. Game Informer said Infinity Ward “can still deliver compelling military-FPS experiences.” The campaign’s conclusion to the Korean storyline satisfies, and the revived DMZ mode is the standout — chaotic and unpredictable in the way the format demands.
It is not a clean sweep. Strict matchmaking produces sweaty lobbies and long queues; map layouts and spawns are uneven, and the Gunsmith suffers attachment bloat. Game Informer found some character arcs rushed; The Guardian doubted it would win new converts. But an 84 for a yearly franchise entry is markedly better than recent instalments managed.
So does the PS5 Pro finally make sense?
Yes — but the answer splits cleanly in two, and anyone expecting the Pro to deliver 60fps in Rockstar’s new game is about to be disappointed.
GTA VI: image quality, not frames
Digital Foundry’s technical analysis is unambiguous. GTA VI targets 30fps on every console, the PS5 Pro included. There is no performance mode. Rockstar’s position, as reported, is that the Pro’s CPU cannot sustain 60fps at this scale of world simulation.
What the Pro actually buys you, PS5 against PS5 Pro:
Internal resolution: 1440p on both.
Upscaling: Rockstar TAA → 4K on PS5, PSSR 2 → 4K on PS5 Pro.
Ray tracing: GI + reflections on PS5, GI + reflections + shadows on PS5 Pro.
Frame rate target: 30fps on both.
Stress-test low: 23fps on PS5, 24fps on PS5 Pro.
The internal resolution is identical. The frame-rate ceiling is identical. In Digital Foundry’s car-explosion stress test the Pro bottomed out at 24fps against the base console’s 23 — a difference of one frame.
What is genuinely better is the picture. PSSR 2 produces sharpness Digital Foundry describes as close to native 4K, well ahead of the base machine’s TAA, and ray-traced shadows are Pro-exclusive. In normal play the Pro holds its 30fps where the base PS5 wobbles. On a game most buyers will spend a hundred hours inside, a cleaner image and a steadier lock are not nothing — but they are a different product from the one many Pro owners thought they were buying. For reference, Xbox Series X mostly holds 30fps but drops to around 20 in heavy combat; Series S runs 720p internally, upscaled to 1080p via FSR 4.
Modern Warfare 4: this is the one
Here the Pro does exactly what it was sold to do. Sony’s own materials describe the Pro build as taking full advantage of PSSR, improving visuals in both the 120Hz and 60Hz modes, and — critically — unlocking the frame rate so it can exceed 120fps with the right settings.
That is the Pro’s actual thesis, delivered. A competitive shooter where frame rate is the entire point, running past 120fps with better upscaling than the base console manages. If you bought a Pro for responsiveness, MW4 is where the money shows up. GTA VI is where it shows up as pixels.
The awkward part: the price went the wrong way
An honest assessment has to deal with the cost side, and it is not favourable.
Sony raised recommended prices across the line on 2 April 2026. US pricing now stands at $599.99 for the Digital Edition, $649.99 for the standard PS5, and $899.99 for the 2TB Pro. In Europe the Pro lists at €899.99, and £789.99 in the UK. The increase is widely attributed to the global memory and storage component squeeze that has pushed hardware costs up across the entire electronics market this year — the same shortage reshaping smartphone pricing.
Availability is worse. CNET reported the Pro out of stock at Best Buy, Amazon, Walmart, Target and PlayStation Direct continuously since 19 September, with Sony telling distributors in September that supply would stay constrained into 2027. Japan ran a purchase lottery with applications closing 8 October. The console is scarce or sold out across Amazon, Best Buy, MediaMarkt and Yodobashi.
So the Pro arrives at its moment of maximum relevance roughly $200 more expensive than at launch and largely unbuyable. That is a strange definition of vindication.
The verdict
The thesis holds, with one correction.
The PS5 Pro now has a reason to exist that it conspicuously lacked through 2025, when it was an expensive solution to a problem few games posed. Two of the biggest releases of the generation landed inside four weeks, and both are demonstrably better on it — MW4 through raw frame rate, GTA VI through image quality and stability. A machine bought in anticipation of exactly this is no longer speculative.
But if the purchase was justified to yourself as “GTA VI will run at 60,” that reasoning was wrong, and Digital Foundry’s numbers close the argument. The Pro’s GTA VI advantage is a sharper, more stable 30fps with better shadows — worth having, not transformative.
And for anyone still deciding: at $899.99, sold out into 2027, against a base PS5 running the same internal resolution at the same frame-rate target, the case is far weaker than for someone who already owns one. The people whose purchase just started to make sense are the people who already made it.
References
Output Lag, GTA 6 review roundup: 99 on Metacritic, and not a single mixed or negative review, 18 Nov 2026
The Next Web, GTA VI ties Metacritic’s all-time record with a 99 as it launches, Nov 2026
FandomWire, GTA 6: Metacritic Officially Confirms a 99 Score From Critics at Launch, Nov 2026
Technobezz, GTA 6 Scores 99 on Metacritic, Tied With Ocarina of Time, Nov 2026
GameDaily, Modern Warfare 4 Wins Critics Back With A Campaign Finale And DMZ, Despite Matchmaking Gripes — gamedaily.com/games/call-of-duty-modern-warfare-4-review-roundup
Metacritic, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 — metacritic.com/game/call-of-duty-modern-warfare-4/
OpenCritic, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 — opencritic.com/game/20690/
MobiDevices, GTA 6 graphics compared on Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5 and PS5 Pro (Digital Foundry analysis) — mobidevices.com/en/gta-6-digital-foundry
TweakTown, GTA 6 deemed ‘the single most visually striking game of the generation’ by tech experts, Nov 2026
Tom’s Guide, What’s the point in PS5 Pro if I can’t play GTA 6 in 60 fps on it?
TheGamer, PlayStation Details Impressive Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 PS5 Pro Features, Oct 2026
Shattered.io, GTA 6 Is 3 Days Out: PS5 $649.99, Pro $899.99 — pricing and CNET stock reporting, Nov 2026
Notes. Scores are live and move as reviews arrive; figures as at 18–19 Nov 2026. MW4’s 84 is the PC Metascore — PS5 and Switch 2 had none at the time of writing. Digital Foundry findings are reported via ref 8. MW4 Pro frame-rate claims originate with Sony and Activision marketing, not independent testing. Prices are Sony recommended, effective 2 Apr 2026, and vary by retailer and region.
More in Markets
Markets
Has Apple already reached the top?
Markets
What to play this winter: the big games of Q4 2026
Markets
Salt instead of scarcity: how CATL’s sodium battery launch redraws the map of the energy transition
Markets
Quick hits: TikTok saved, sort of, and SpaceX swallows xAI in the largest merger in history